Boys and Broccolini
The Beatitudes may seems old and out of date but they are an excellent example of cause and effect, the efficacy or causality that believes one thing had a direct result on the outcome. While the words of the Beatitudes may seem ancient, their basic construct is used all over the world by parents, politicians, cult leaders, and terrorist factions.
Before you get all upset because I put parents in the same grouping as politicians and leaders of terrorist cells, please read on. When it comes to persuasive speech, they all have a great deal in common. Many of us from several generations ago were admonished not to make faces or else, we were told, our face would freeze that way. Another less understood adage was that we were to eat all our vegetables because there were starving children in the world.
Writing for the website explorable.com, Martyn Shuttleworth explains why such a persuasive argument is often incorrect and misleading. “The basic principle of causality is determining whether the results and trends seen in an experiment are actually caused by the manipulation or whether some other factor may underlie the process. Unfortunately, the media and politicians often jump upon scientific results and proclaim that it conveniently fits their beliefs and policies. Some scientists, fixated upon ‘proving’ that their view of the world is correct, leak their results to the press before allowing the peer review process to check and validate their work.”
Growing up in the city Maria was completely out of her element when her family moved to a small town of less than one thousand. She attended a weekend dance shortly after moving to the area which was held at a community center. Five days later a classmate sat down beside her at lunch and introduced herself. “Hi, I’m Priscilla. My older brother is best friends with Jackley who plays ball with Billy. His younger brother is in our class because he flunked kindergarten. His brother is named Logan but he sits on the other side of the room so you might not have noticed him. He’s best friends with Josh who lives next door to me. Anyway, Logan told Josh he likes you. He saw you at the dance, you see. So, do you like him?” Lost amid all the names and siblings, Maria smiled hesitantly and replied: “If he likes me, then he and I should talk about it.” Priscilla tossed her head backed and turned to the other girls standing around. “She’s a snob.” They all left and Maria ate lunch by herself for two weeks.
While there was really nothing wrong with Maria’s response, it was that of some a few years older and from a completely different environment than those who had grown up knowing each other. The cause and effect might indicate that perhaps Maria really was acting like a snob or that the other girls just wanted to gossip. It might also, depending on how the information was evaluated, indicate that the girls were reaching out to Maria the best way they knew. We really do not know without more information regarding posture, tone and inflection, etc. What is clear is that the cause – the professed interest of one boy to the new girl in the class – had a less than desirable effect for all involved.
We often make assumptions that may or may not hold true. Take, for instance, the vegetable broccoli. It is a member of the cabbage family and can be eaten raw or cooked. Broccoli rabe and broccolini might be considered parts of the broccoli plant but they are actually different plants entirely. A lobbyist for a vegetable company might try to persuade politicians to consider substituting one for the other in a school lunch program. A less than informed populous might think that was okay. There are differences, though.
Broccolini is a natural hybrid of broccoli with Chinese chard. It gets its length from the chard and smaller florets on top from the broccoli. Broccoli rabe, however, is more closely akin to the turnip than to broccoli. Nutritionally, there are great differences. A serving of broccoli rabe has 144 calories while a serving of broccoli has 31. Both broccoli and broccolini had over 100% of the recommended daily allowance for vitamin C but broccoli rabe has 270% for vitamin C. The eating of one of these three is not the same as the others so the effect on the body nutritionally would vary greatly.
It may seem like the Beatitudes are an ancient cause and effect rambling but really, they are as relevant today as they were almost two thousand years ago. They offer us causality but also a positive effect. It really depends on our perspective and how willing we are to see the positive. Maria did eventually become friend with Logan but that was all. Once the girls realized Maria had already had the chapters they were currently studying and she could help them pass their world geography class, they befriended her. It took some time and patience and yes, a few tears were shed, but happiness was the final result.
Eating that serving of broccolini may not instantly taste delicious but your body will really appreciate its positive effects. It is up to us to determine how we approach the causes and subsequent effects in our own lives. We ultimately have control of our responses and our willingness to wait out the goodness that life can offer. By defining accurately the causes in our lives and then evaluating the effects and everything influencing them as well as our own responses, we have a much better chance of improving our living. Today’s chaos might just turn out to be tomorrow’s blessing.